Originally published: 1895
Genres: Mystery
Goodreads link: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/204172671-a-lady-in-black
Gutenberg link: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/72314
Chapters: 15
Warning: This may include outdated and derogatory language and attitudes.
CHAPTER I
A MYSTERY SOMEWHERE
“And besides, you know, my dear Mrs. Rose, there is generally something wrong about a woman who dresses so very well.”
So spoke Mrs. Bonnington, the Vicar’s wife, laying down the law; a law indeed, which most English women are ready to take for granted. Mrs. Rose, a tall, thin, pale lady who had “nerves,” and who, on this bright April morning, wore a woolen shawl half off her shoulders as she sat in the warm sun by the dining room window, assented readily.
“That’s what I always say. Especially a widow. I’m sure if anything were to happen to my husband,” went on Mrs. Rose euphemistically, “the last thing I should think about would be my dress. I should be far too unhappy to trouble myself about the fit of my dresses or the shape of my bonnets.”
Now this was perhaps true, as Mrs. Rose, though she spent as much money and as much thought upon her clothes as her compeers, never succeeded in looking as if her clothes had been made for her, or as if the subject of “fit” were of any importance.
Mrs. Bonnington shook her head with vague disquietude and resumed her homily.
“I assure you the matter has caused me a good deal of anxiety. You know how solicitous both the Vicar and I are about the tone of the parish.”
“I do indeed,” murmured Mrs. Rose sympathetically.
“You know how hard we work to keep up a high standard. Why, everybody knows that it was through us that those objectionable people at Colwyn Lodge went away, and how we would do anything to rid the place of those terrible Solomons at Stone Court!”
At the other end of the room, a young face, with gray eyes full of mischief, was turned in the direction of Mrs. Bonnington with a satirical smile. Mabin Rose, the overgrown, awkward step-daughter of Mrs. Rose, who hated the Vicar’s wife, and called her a busybody and a gossip, brought her darning nearer to the table and dashed headlong into the fray.
“Papa wouldn’t thank you if you did drive the Solomons out of the parish, as you did the people at Colwyn Lodge, Mrs. Bonnington,” broke in the clear young voice that would be heard. “He says Mr. Solomon is the best tenant he ever had, and that he wishes that some of the Christians were like him.”
“Hush, Mabin. Go on with your work, and don’t interrupt with your rude remarks,” said Mrs. Rose sharply. “I am quite sure your father never said such a thing, except perhaps in fun,” she went on, turning apologetically to her visitor. “Nobody is more anxious about ‘tone’ and all those things than Mr. Rose, and he was saying only yesterday that he would rather I didn’t call upon this Mrs. Dale until something more was known about her.”
Again the young face at the other end of the table looked up mutinously, but this time Mabin controlled her inclination to protest. She looked down again and began to darn furiously, to the relief of her feelings, but to the injury of the stocking.
Mrs. Bonnington went on:
“You were quite right. It’s not that I wish to be uncharitable.”
“Of course not,” assented Mrs. Rose with fervor.
“But a woman like yourself, with daughters to take care of, cannot be too careful. Young people are so easily led away; they think so much of the mere outside. They are so easily dazzled and taken in by appearances.”
Mabin grew red, perceiving that this little sermon by the way was directed at herself. Her step-sisters, Emily and Ethel, one of whom could be heard “practicing” in the drawing room, were not the sort of girls to be led away by anything.
“But why shouldn’t a nice face mean something nice?” put in the rash young woman again.
The fact was that Mabin had been charmed with the sweet pink-and-white face and blue eyes of Mrs. Dale, their new neighbor at “The Towers,” and was mentally comparing the widow’s childlike charms with the acidulated attractions of the Vicar’s dowdy wife.
“And why,” pursued Mabin, as both the elder ladies seemed to pause to gain strength to fall upon her together, “shouldn’t she be just as sorry for her husband’s death because she looks nice over it? It seemed to me, when she sat near us at church on Sunday, that she had the saddest face I had ever seen. And as for her corrupting us by her ‘tone,’ she won’t have anything to do with any of us. Mrs. Warren has called upon her, and the Miss Bradleys and Mrs. Peak and a lot more people, and she’s always ‘not at home.’ So even if she is wicked, I should think you might let her stay. Surely she can’t do us much harm just by having her frocks better made than the rest of us.”
When Mabin had finished this outrageous speech, there was an awful pause. Mrs. Rose hardly knew how to administer such a reproof as should be sufficiently scathing; while Mrs. Bonnington waited in solemn silence for the reproof to come. Mabin looked from her stepmother’s face to that of the Vicar’s wife and thought she had better retire before the avalanche descended. So she gathered up her work hastily, running her darning needle into her hand in her excitement, muttered an awkward apology and excuse for her disappearance at the same time, and shot out of the room in the ungainly way that had so often before caused her stepmother to shudder, as she did now.
When the door had closed upon the girl, closed, unfortunately, with a bang, Mrs. Bonnington sighed.
“I am afraid,” she said, unconsciously assuming still more of her usual clerical tone and accent, “that Mabin must be a great anxiety to you!”
Mrs. Rose sighed and closed her eyes for a moment, wearily.
“If you could realize how great an anxiety,” she murmured in a solemn tone, “you would pity me! If it were not that Mr. Rose gives his authority to support mine in dealing with her, she would be absolutely unmanageable, I assure you.”
“A forward spirit! And one singularly unsusceptible to good influences,” said the Vicar’s wife. “However, we must persevere with her, and hope for a future blessing on our labors, even if it should come too late for us to be witnesses of her regeneration.”
“I am sure I have always done my best for her and treated her just as I have my own children. But you see with what different results! The seed is the same, but the soil is not. I don’t know whether you knew her mother? But I suppose Mabin must take after her. She is utterly unlike her father.”
“She is indeed. Mr. Rose is such a particularly judicious, upright man. The Vicar has the highest respect for him.”
Mrs. Bonnington paused, to give full effect to this noble encomium. Mrs. Rose acknowledged it by a graceful bend of the head, and went on:
“The great failing about poor Mabin is that she is not womanly. And that is the one thing above all that my husband asks of a woman. Let her only be womanly, he always says, and I will forgive everything else. Now my own girls are that, above everything.”
“Ah!” exclaimed Mrs. Bonnington with decision; “but that is just the fault of our age, Mrs. Rose. Girls are no longer brought up to be contented to be girls. They must put themselves on the same footing as their brothers. Mabin is in the fashion. And no doubt that is all she desires. You see how this Mrs. Dale has caught hold of her imagination, by nothing but her fashionable clothes!”
Mrs. Rose put on a womanly air of absolute helplessness:
“Well, what can I do?” said she.
Mrs. Bonnington came a little nearer.
“In the case of this Mrs. Dale,” said she in a lower voice, “go on just as you have begun. Do not call upon her. Do not have anything to do with her. To tell you the truth, it was about her that I came to see you this morning. She has already brought mischief into our own peaceful home. She is a dangerous woman.”
“Dear me! You don’t mean that!” said Mrs. Rose with vivid interest.
“Unhappily I do. My son Rudolph came back from his ship only ten days ago, and already he can think of nothing but this Mrs. Dale.”
“After having had the unpardonable insolence to leave your call unreturned, she has got hold of your son?” gasped Mrs. Rose.
“Well, not exactly that, as far as I know,” admitted the Vicar’s wife. “He says he has never spoken to her. And the dear boy has never told me an untruth before.”
“But if this dreadful woman has entangled him, of course, she might make him say anything!” cried Mrs. Rose in sympathetic agonies.
“I should not like to accuse a fellow woman of doing that,” replied Mrs. Bonnington, severely; “but I think it is a bad and unnatural sign, when my son, who has never taken the least notice of any of the young girls in the neighborhood, becomes absorbed, in a few days, in the doings of a person who is a complete stranger to him and who calls herself a widow.”
“Then don’t you think,” purred Mrs. Rose, with the eagerness of one who scents a scandal, “that she is a widow?”
There was a pause. And Mrs. Bonnington spoke next, with the deliberation of one who has a great duty to perform.
“I should be very sorry to have it said of me that I was the first to start a rumor which might be thought unchristian or unkind,” she said with a deprecatory wave of the brown cotton gloves she wore in the mornings. “But I have thought it my duty to make inquiries, and I deeply regret to say that I have found out several things which lead me to the conclusion that this person has settled down in our midst under false pretenses.”
“You don’t say so!”
“You shall judge for yourself. In the first place, although she calls herself Mrs. Dale, the initials on some of her linen are ‘D. M.’ Now M. does not stand for ‘Dale,’ does it?”
“Perhaps her maiden name began with M.,” suggested Mrs. Rose.
“My informant tells me,” went on Mrs. Bonnington as if offended by the interruption, “that in her old books, school books, and work of that sort, there is written the name ‘Dorothy Leatham.’ So she seems to have passed already by three different names. I leave it to your own common sense whether that is not a curious circumstance, considering that she is still young.”
“It is certainly curious, very curious. And—and—”
Mrs. Rose hardly liked to ask on what authority her visitor made these statements, which savored strongly of the back-stairs. She had hardly paused an instant before Mrs. Bonnington rushed into further details:
“And now here is another thing which is very strange: her servants have none of them been with her long. They were all engaged together, three months ago in London, not by Mrs. Dale herself, but by an old lady whose name nobody seems to know. Now isn’t that rather remarkable? They all came down here, and had the place ready for their mistress before they so much as saw her.”
Mrs. Bonnington leaned back in her chair and drew on her brown cotton gloves further. Mrs. Rose wondered again as to the source of this information. She felt a little ashamed of listening to all this gossip, and was less inclined than her friend to take a suspicious view of the case, strange though it was. So she contented herself with murmured interjections, to fill up the pause before Mrs. Bonnington went on again:
“However, I have got a clue as to where she came from, for a van-load of furniture came down before she arrived, and it came from Todcaster.”
“Todcaster!” echoed Mrs. Rose. “Then we shall soon know something more about her. Mr. Rose’s old friend, Mrs. Haybrow, is coming down to see us early next month. She lived near Todcaster when she was a girl, and she often goes back to the old place, and keeps in touch with all the people there.”
“Well,” said Mrs. Bonnington, rising from her chair, and speaking in a rather more stilted tone than at first, with the consciousness that her news had hardly been received as she had expected, “I sincerely trust we may find we have been mistaken. No one will rejoice more unfeignedly than I if she proves to be indeed what she gives herself out to be. Indeed, if she had received me frankly at the outset, I would have shown her such Christian sympathy as one soul can give to another without asking any questions. And it is only in the interests of our young people that I lift up my voice now.”
The Vicar’s wife then took her leave and went on her way to complete her morning rounds. She was rather a terrible person, this little, faded middle-aged woman with the curate’s voice and the curate’s manner, uniting, as she did, a desperate interest in other people’s affairs with a profound conviction that her interference in them could only be for good. But she had her good points. A devoted, submissive, and worshipful wife, she modified her worship by considering herself the Vicar’s guardian angel. A parish busybody and tyrant, she never spared herself and could show true womanly kindness to such of her husband’s parishioners as were not of “a froward spirit.”
Unluckily, she had not the power of conciliating, but had, on the contrary, a grand talent for raising up antagonism in unregenerate minds like those of the unfortunate Mabin.
The young girl had been both sorry and ashamed at her own loss of temper. Not that an outburst such as that she had indulged in was any unusual thing. Like many young girls of spirit under the injudicious rule, Mabin was in a state of perpetual friction with those around her. Her step-mother was not intentionally unkind, but poor Mabin had to suffer from the constant comparison of her unruly and independent self with her quiet and insipid half-sisters.
And the worst of it was that her father was even less indulgent than his wife to her waywardness. A stiff, straight-laced, narrow-minded man, accustomed to being looked up to and deferred to by the female members of his household, he disapproved in the strongest manner both of the erratic moods of his eldest daughter and of her longing for independence. It was from him, indeed, that Mabin chiefly suffered. She looked upon the cold, handsome, aquiline face of her father with something very much like horror, and the mere fact that he approved only of submissive “womanly” women seemed to goad her into the very rebelliousness and independence that shocked him so deeply.
At the same time that he disapproved of her, however, Mr. Rose did not hesitate to avail himself of his daughter’s bright wits; and if any task requiring a little thought or a little judgment presented itself, it was always upon Mabin’s shoulders that he put the burden.
He had even gone so far, protesting loudly the while against the “unfeminine” practice, as to allow Mabin to ride a bicycle; and it was on this machine that the girl was expected to go into Seagate two or three times a week, to fetch him his books and magazines from the local library.
As Mrs. Bonnington descended the steps of the big stone house, and, emerging from the portico, made her way down the broad gravel path to the gate, she met Mabin coming out by the side gate among the evergreens with her bicycle by her side.
Now if there was one thing more detestable in the eyes of the Vicar’s wife than another, it was a bicycle. But this detestation increased tenfold when the rider of the obnoxious machine was a woman. It was her one grievance against upright Mr. Rose that he allowed his nineteen-year-old daughter to “career about the country” on the abominable thing.
She uttered an involuntary “Ugh!” of disgust as the thing almost touched her uplifted skirts.
“I beg your pardon. I hope I didn’t run against you. I am so clumsy,” said Mabin with studied politeness.
“You can’t expect to be anything but clumsy while you use such a thing as that!” said Mrs. Bonnington severely. “I wish for your own sake it would get broken, that you might never be seen in an attitude so unbecoming to a gentlewoman again.”
“Is it you who tell your sons to throw stones at it when I am riding past the Vicarage?” said Mabin, trying to speak civilly, while the blood rose to her cheeks. “Walter struck the hind wheel two days ago, and now I have to walk as long as I am within stone’s-throw of your garden wall.”
“I have heard nothing about it,” said Mrs. Bonnington icily.
“Of course you wouldn’t,” said Mabin, keeping her tone in check. “But I see Rudolph has taken to riding one too since he’s been back. So if they throw stones at me, I can have my revenge upon him,” she concluded darkly.
“If girls unsex themselves, they can’t expect to be treated with the chivalry they used to receive,” said Mrs. Bonnington, as, not caring to continue the encounter with the rebellious one, she turned her back, and went down the hill.
Comments